Key West Margarita

Finding the Best Margarita in Key West

So, you’re on a quest for the holy grail of margaritas, huh? Well, get ready to have your taste buds transported to a whole new level of tequila-infused bliss in Key West.

From the moment you step foot on this tropical paradise, you’ll be bombarded with options that will leave you in a margarita-induced haze. Picture this: charming cafes with happy hours that serve up freshly squeezed margaritas that will make you question if you’re actually in Key West or a Margaritaville dream.

And that’s just the beginning! But hey, why settle for ordinary when you can have extraordinary? So, grab your sombrero and get ready to embark on a margarita adventure that will have you yearning for more.

Pepe’s Cafe

If you’re searching for the holy grail of margaritas in Key West, look no further than Pepe’s Cafe, the oldest bar in town where even President Truman couldn’t resist sneaking out for a happy hour cocktail.

This place is legendary, like the unicorn of margaritas. They’ve been perfecting their margarita game for years, and let me tell you, they’ve got it down to an art. It’s like they took the essence of Key West and squeezed it right into your glass.

The bartenders at Pepe’s are like mad scientists, concocting the most delicious, refreshing margaritas you’ve ever tasted. And they don’t mess around with those pre-made mixes or fancy margarita machines. Oh no, they squeeze every single lime by hand, because that’s how they roll in Key West.

So if you want the best margarita in Key West, grab yourself a seat at Pepe’s and let the magic happen. Don’t forget to pair it with some half-priced oysters during happy hour. Trust me, it’s a match made in margarita heaven.

And while you’re at it, why not make a day of it and explore all the other amazing Key West excursions? Just make sure Pepe’s is your first stop, because once you taste their margarita, you won’t want to go anywhere else.

Bad Boy Taqueria and Tequila

Bad Boy Burrito, the new kid on the block over at The Perry Hotel and Marina on Stock Island, is serving up margaritas that will make your taste buds do a happy dance.

Now, you might be thinking, what makes Bad Boy Burrito’s margarita so special? Well, let me tell you. First of all, they use the freshest ingredients. None of that pre-packaged sour mix nonsense. Oh no, they make their own sour mix from scratch, squeezing every last drop of tangy goodness from those limes.

But it’s not just the ingredients that make this margarita stand out. It’s the atmosphere too. Picture this: you’re sitting by the pool, soaking up the sun while watching the boats come in and out of the marina, with a margarita in hand. The cool breeze is blowing through your hair, and the sound of laughter fills the air. It’s like you’re in your own little slice of paradise.

Sloppy Joes

If you’re looking to sip on a margarita that has a touch of Key West’s legendary charm, head on over to Sloppy Joes and prepare to embark on a taste bud adventure like no other.

Now, let me tell you about Sloppy Joes. It’s not just a place to grab a drink, it’s a cultural institution. This iconic bar has been serving up liquid magic since 1933, and it’s no wonder that it’s a favorite hangout spot for locals like Earnest Hemmingway and tourists alike.

When it comes to margaritas, Sloppy Joes doesn’t disappoint. They’ve a variety of options to satisfy any margarita connoisseur. From the classic frozen margarita to the locally famous Sloppy Rita, their creations will have you saying, ‘¡Olé!’

But Sloppy Joes isn’t just about the drinks. It’s about the atmosphere. Sloppy Joes Bar in Key West, Florida is lively and energetic, with live music and a bustling crowd. It has a welcoming and laid-back vibe, making it a great place to relax and enjoy a drink with friends.


Ah, Margaritaville, the enchanting land where every day is a beach day and the margaritas flow like a never-ending stream of paradise. You can’t come to Key West and not have a margarita at Jimmy Buffet’s original Margaritaville. Sure, they may not make the best margaritas on the island, but hey, it’s all about the experience, right? Step into this tropical oasis and you’ll be surrounded by laid-back vibes, Hawaiian shirts, and a soundtrack of island tunes that will transport you straight to the land of no worries.

Now, let’s talk about the margaritas themselves. They may not be the most authentic or meticulously crafted, but they sure know how to satisfy that craving for a sweet and tangy concoction. Whether you prefer it frozen or on the rocks, Margaritaville has got you covered. Sip on their signature ‘Who’s to Blame’ margarita, a delightful blend of tequila, lime juice, and a splash of orange liqueur.

It may not be a masterpiece, but it’ll do the job of quenching your thirst and putting a smile on your face.

Agave 308

Nestled on Front Street, just off of Duval Street, lies the tequila haven known as Agave 308, where the margaritas are top shelf and the variety of tequilas is enough to make any agave aficionado weak in the knees.

As you walk into Agave 308 you will find yourself surrounded by walls lined with shelves upon shelves of tequila bottles. It’s like Willy Wonka’s chocolate factory, but for tequila lovers. You’ll feel like a kid in a candy store, except instead of candy, it’s tequila.

The margaritas at Agave 308 aren’t your average margaritas. Oh no, these margaritas are crafted with love and precision. They use only the finest ingredients, from the top-shelf tequila to the freshly squeezed lime juice. It’s like a symphony of flavors dancing in your mouth, leaving you craving for more.

And let’s not forget about the Mezcalita. This spicy, smoky concoction is a true game-changer. It’s like a fiesta in your mouth, with every sip taking you on a journey to flavor town.

But Agave 308 isn’t just about the margaritas. It’s a place where tequila enthusiasts gather to share their love for this magical spirit. You’ll find yourself surrounded by fellow agave aficionados, swapping stories and recommendations. It’s a community, a place where everyone speaks the language of tequila.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is the History Behind Pepe’s Cafe and Its Famous Margaritas?

So you wanna know the scoop on Pepe’s Cafe and its famous margaritas? Well, let me tell you, this place has been slingin’ margaritas since forever. It’s the oldest bar in Key West and even had President Truman sneakin’ out for a happy hour cocktail. Cheers to that!

What Different Types of Margaritas Available at Sloppy Joes?

Well, let me tell you about Sloppy Joe’s margaritas. They’ve got the agave margarita, classic frozen margarita, and the locally famous sloppy rita. Each one has its own unique flavor that’ll make your taste buds dance with joy. Cheers!

What Is the Significance of Margaritaville in Key West and What Makes Their Margaritas Special?

Margaritaville in Key West is famous because, let’s be honest, you can’t come here and not have a margarita at Jimmy Buffet’s original joint. They may not be the best, but they’re a must-try. Cheers!


So, after exploring the vibrant margarita scene in Key West, it’s clear that finding the best margarita is like searching for buried treasure.

From the fresh squeezed margaritas at Pepe’s Cafe to the high-end offerings at Bad Boy Burrito, every sip transports you to a tropical paradise.

Whether you’re sipping at Sloppy Joes, Margaritaville, or Agave 308, each margarita is a flavor adventure that will make your taste buds dance.

So grab a glass, raise it high, and cheers to the endless margarita possibilities in Key West!